A bold reality check: even the most celebrated duos can’t escape the glare of comparison when a single, unified dream team crosses two rugby eras. Former World Cup winner Stephen Donald has attempted just that by merging the standout players from the All Blacks’ 2011 and 2015 title runs with the Springboks’ 2019 and 2023 triumphs into one combined starting XV.
Backs
15 Israel Dagg: Despite a controversial exclusion from the 2015 final, Dagg’s influence across both campaigns was substantial. In 2011 he finished with five tries and earned the number 15 jersey, passing the baton from the venerable Mils Muliaina in the final.
14 Cheslin Kolbe: One of rugby’s most elusive wingers, Kolbe’s pace and footwork unsettled England in the 2019 final and continued to be a pivotal force during the tough knockout phase of the 2023 World Cup.
13 Conrad Smith: A cornerstone of both All Blacks title runs this century, Smith started all six matches in 2015 and retired as a world champion.
12 Ma’a Nonu: Still playing top-tier rugby at 42, Nonu stands as one of the sport’s greatest centers. A powerhouse who featured prominently for both 2011 and 2015 campaigns, starting in both finals.
11 Julian Savea: Described by Donald as “Jonah Lomu-esque,” Savea carried the nickname “The Bus” for a reason—his 2015 form shut down defenses as if they were paper. A career peak that fans won’t forget.
10 Dan Carter: While Handré Pollard’s clutch exploits are famed, Carter’s stature as one of rugby’s greatest ever players is undeniable. Though hampered by injury in 2011, Carter delivered in spades in 2015.
9 Aaron Smith: Arguably one of the greatest scrum-halves of all time, Smith’s influence overshadows Faf de Klerk’s 2019 prominence when selecting this combined XI.
Forwards
8 Duane Vermeulen: A towering presence in the Springboks’ pack, Vermeulen’s performance earned him Man of the Match honors in both finals, a feat that even Kieran Read couldn’t outshine.
7 Richie McCaw: Widely regarded by many as rugby’s greatest, McCaw captained the All Blacks to two World Cup titles and later received the World Rugby Player of the Decade award in 2021.
6 Pieter-Steph du Toit: A two-time World Rugby Player of the Year, PSDT is celebrated as one of the hardest hitters in the sport and a defining figure of both 2019 and 2023 campaigns.
5 Eben Etzebeth: A talisman of the Springbok pack, Etzebeth remains the most-capped South African and was central to the World Cup-winning squads.
4 Brodie Retallick: Retiring after the 2023 final with an enormous caps tally, he’s a former World Rugby Player of the Year and widely regarded among the game’s greatest locks.
3 Owen Franks: Another All Black stalwart, Franks was a tireless scrummager and relentless tackler who helped push New Zealand to two World Cups.
2 Dane Coles: While Malcolm Marx was a strong contender, Coles’ relaunching of the scrum and dynamic play outranked him in this lineup for Donald’s preferred style.
1 Ox Nché: A remarkably powerful athlete whose scrum dominance earned him a World Rugby Player of the Year nomination this year, Nché balances brute power with polished ball skills, contributing to back-to-back World Cup wins.
READ MORE: Loose Pass: Rugby’s search for ‘perfection’ continues as relentless negativity mooching rages on
